Grammar Q & A Newsgroup

Click on Questions and Answers to see the newest messages. If you want to post a message or comment, you will be prompted to login. (If you are not registered, you can do so from the login box.) Remember to bookmark this page to make it easier to return to it.

    Grammar Exchange    Grammar Exchange  Hop To Forum Categories  The Grammar Exchange  Hop To Forums  Questions and Answers    How do you see "look at"...
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
How do you see "look at"...
 Login/Join 
<MikeyC>
Posted   Report This Post  
How do you see "look at" in the sentence below?

He stared at the moon.

1. (simple) verb + prepositional phrase (consisting of Prep + NP, in turn).
2. (complex) verb (consisting of V + Prep) and NP (as object).
Member
Posts: 558
Posted   Hide PostReport This Post  
I guess you were asking about phrasal verbs or verbs with objects.

He stared at the moon. stare (verb) + prepositional phrase. We have phrasal verbs when used with out/down like stare somebody out/down.

Likewise, in He looked at the moon look + prepositional phrase if you just mean he directed his eyes in order to see the moon.

However, look at (phrasal verb) + objects as in the following sentences:

1. Management is looking at ways of cutting costs. (look at = think about something carefully so that you can make a decision about it)
2. If I'd had children I might have looked at things differently. (look at = to consider something in a particular way )
3. Can you look at my essay sometime? (look at = to read something in order to check it or form an opinion about it )
4. Did you get the doctor to look at your knee? (look at = If someone, usually an expert, looks at something, they examine it )

These examples are taken from Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary. Hope this can help.
<MikeyC>
Posted   Report This Post  
quote:
I guess you were asking about phrasal verbs or verbs with objects.


I was asking more about prepositional verbs than phrasal ones. Some see "stare at" as the former while other see it as V + PP.

e.g.

stare at/the moon
stare/at the moon

As for phrasal verbs vs prepositional verbs:

He tore off the price tag. (phrasal verb)
The tearing off of the price tag was recorded on camera.

He stared at the moon. (prepositional verb)
*His staring at of the moon was strange to see.

he tore it off
*he looked it at

This message has been edited. Last edited by: <MikeyC>,
<MikeyC>
Posted   Report This Post  
quote:
Likewise, in He looked at the moon look + prepositional phrase if you just mean he directed his eyes in order to see the moon.

However, look at (phrasal verb) + objects as in the following sentences:


<<Likewise, in He looked at the moon look + prepositional phrase if you just mean he directed his eyes in order to see the moon.

However, look at (phrasal verb) + objects as in the following sentences:>>

So the difference between "look at" as a unit and as two seperate words is that the former is idiomatic, in the wider sense of that word. Am I right?

This message has been edited. Last edited by: <MikeyC>,
Member
Posts: 18417
Posted   Hide PostReport This Post  
I see 'look at' as a prepositional verb.

We have had some interesting discussions on this subject, MikeyC. Here is one: http://thegrammarexchange.info...=401109904#401109904
  Powered by Social Strata  
 

    Grammar Exchange    Grammar Exchange  Hop To Forum Categories  The Grammar Exchange  Hop To Forums  Questions and Answers    How do you see "look at"...