|
|
|
Grammar
Q & A Newsgroup
Click on Questions
and Answers to see the newest messages. If you want
to post a message or comment, you will be
prompted to login. (If you are not registered, you can do so
from the login box.) Remember to bookmark this page to make
it easier to return to it. |
Go 
|
New 
|
Find 
|
Notify 
|
|
Reply 
|
|
Admin 
|
New PM! 
|
Member
Location: Taiwan
Posts: 311
|
Dear moderators: Is the following sentence grammatically correct? Do you have art class today?
|
Member
Posts: 11498
|
Yes, Joan, it's fine.
Richard
|
Member
Location: Taiwan
Posts: 311
|
Why is the sentence fine with no article before "art class" or without using the plural countable noun phrase "art classes" ?Is "art class" countable or uncountable?
|
Member
Posts: 11498
|
That's a great question, Joan. Art class is being used as the name of this course, and we don't normally use the definite article with names. That's why I wouldn't say "the Joan," at least not in this context. The names for all basic classes are without the definite article: history, geography, typing, art, ceramics, math, etc. By the way, in your example art classes, notice that classes can be singular or plural, but not art since it's the descriptive element of this noun adjunct. Richard Richard
|
Member
Location: Taiwan
Posts: 311
|
quote: The names for all basic classes are without the definite article
Dear Richard: So you mean either the indefinite article or the plural countable noun is also possible version of my example?Like these: Do you have an art class today? Do you have art classes today?
|
Member
Posts: 11498
|
Yes, Joan. Those two questions are just fine!
Richard
|
Member
Posts: 18
|
Hello Richard,
How about just "class" not "art class"? I heard my friend say:
"We can leave now, class is over."
Can I say: "We can leave now, the class is over"? will it sound awkward this way?
|
Member
Posts: 11498
|
Even though it's more common simply to say Class is over, Joan, it's okay to say The class is over, too.
By the way, your example needs to be tweaked. You can write it one of two ways.
as two sentences: We can leave now. Class is over.
OR
as one sentence, but with a semi-colon, not a comma: We can leave now; class is over.
|
Member
Posts: 18
|
Many thanks for the extra information on punctuation! 
|
 | Please Wait. Your request is being processed... |
|