I have an adverbial clause that begins a sentence and the independent part of the sentence is a list (with commas) of more than three items. I think that I should use a semi-colon to separate the dependent and independent clauses but I'm not sure. help
Replies sorted oldest to newest
Hello, Clueless, and welcome to the Grammar Exchange.
Please give us the example or some variation of it. Thanks.
Ok, here's the variation of the sentence. I hope I didn't muddle it too much. I think a comma after "swim" would be too many but what I've learned so far is that an adverbial clause should be used when it begins a sentence. thanks
Although only ten percent of the population of this country knows how to swim; many of its citizens are world-class swimmers including entrepreneur James Levitt, President Dwight Eisenhower, composer Eric Stevenson, and baseball player Christopher Evans.
@clueless posted:Ok, here's the variation of the sentence. I hope I didn't muddle it too much. I think a comma after "swim" would be too many but what I've learned so far is that an adverbial clause should be used when it begins a sentence. thanks
Although only ten percent of the population of this country knows how to swim; many of its citizens are world-class swimmers including entrepreneur James Levitt, President Dwight Eisenhower, composer Eric Stevenson, and baseball player Christopher Evans.
Hello again, Clueless —The semicolon after "swim" is incorrect. You need a comma there instead. You also need a comma after "swimmers," for a grand total of 5 commas. There is no limit to the number of commas a sentence may have, provided the sentence calls structurally for the insertion of each comma.
- Although only ten percent of the population of this country knows how to swim, many of its citizens are world-class swimmers, including entrepreneur James Levitt, President Dwight Eisenhower, composer Eric Stevenson, and baseball player Christopher Evans.