Skip to main content

1) To that end, this matter has been referred to the Office of Internal Affairs to conduct a full and fair investigation.

Source:
https://www.yahoo.com/now/conn...olice-221551657.html

Is '1' grammatical?

Who is to conduct a full and fair investigation?

It seems to me that from a grammatical point of view the people who have referred the matter to the Office of Internal Affairs are to conduct a full and fair investigation.

However, the real meaning seems to be that the Office of Internal Affairs are going to conduct the investigation.

Consider:


2) I send you this document to study. (you are going to study the document)

3) I send you this document to learn Italian.
I think here I am going to learn Italian.

If it was
4) I send you this document to learn Italian with.
then it'd be you.

Gratefully,
Navi


PS. I think '3' works. One could say that the 'with' which is suppposed to be at the end has been elided.

Last edited by navi
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Hi, Navi,

@navi posted:

1) To that end, this matter has been referred to the Office of Internal Affairs to conduct a full and fair investigation.

Source:
https://www.yahoo.com/now/conn...olice-221551657.html

Is '1' grammatical?

Who is to conduct a full and fair investigation?

It seems to me that from a grammatical point of view the people who have referred the matter to the Office of Internal Affairs are to conduct a full and fair investigation.

However, the real meaning seems to be that the Office of Internal Affairs are going to conduct the investigation.

The sentence is understandable, but I agree that the subject should be made more explicit to avoid any ambiguity:

1a. To that end, this matter has been referred to the Office of Internal Affairs for them to conduct a full and fair investigation.

The problem with the sentence above is the position of the subject. See this other sentence where it is clear who is in charge of the investigation:

1b. The Office of Internal Affairs has been assigned this matter to conduct a full and fair investigation.

@navi posted:

2) I send you this document to study. (you are going to study the document)

3) I send you this document to learn Italian.
I think here I am going to learn Italian.

If it was
4) I send you this document to learn Italian with.
then it'd be you.

Gratefully,
Navi


PS. I think '3' works. One could say that the 'with' which is supposed to be at the end has been elided.

I think (2) and (3) work finely to mean that "you" is the person expected to study and to learn Italian. I think that, unlike in (1), here the proximity between "this document" and the infinitive renders a clearer interpretation of the intended meaning.

Last edited by Gustavo, Co-Moderator

Thank you both very much,

I think we are getting different links or something. Something funny seems to be going on, or I am so exhausted my mind is playing tricks on me.

The article I see has two sentences about the same thing.

The mayor of Bridgeport, Connecticut, announced Monday that the police department's handling of the investigation into the death of a 23-year-old Black woman found unresponsive in her apartment in December by a man she had met on a Bumble date has been referred to its Office of Internal Affairs for an independent investigation.

There is no tolerance for anything less than respect and sensitivity for family members and their loss," he said. "To that end, this matter has been referred to the Office of Internal Affairs to conduct a full and fair investigation."

I am baffled. There's no agnosticism about that! I truly believe in my baffledness!

Respectfully,

Navi

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×