Although I know the basic distinction between "one" and "it", I need a better explanation for the students. Look at the two sentences (1)and (2).

(1) Have you ever seen a panda? Yes, I've seen one.
(2) Have you ever seen snow? Yes I've seen it.

In (1) a panda is not a particular panda but any one of the pandas, so the pronoun is "one" not " it". So far so good. But in (2) snow is any snow, not any particular snow. And yet, the pronoun is "it". "one" is not possible because snow is non count. Is this the reason we use "it" instead of "one"? When the noun is non count, we use "it" instead of "one" even when the object in question is not something specific?

Apple
Original Post
"Snow," is a mass, or noncount, noun. It has no other form (except in literary or other specialized language).

"Panda" is a count noun. Count nouns have three possible forms for the generic. The basic generic form for count nouns is plural:

Pandas are very playful when THEY are young

There are two other generic forms for count nouns: the singular indefinite form "A panda" ("any member of the category") and the form used to refer to the abstract category, the singular "the panda," as in "THE panda is still an endangered species."

The pronoun used for the indefinite singular noun "a panda" is "one." "One" refers, again, to "any member of the category."

In contrast, "snow" is definite and therefore is represented by "it." For example,

Snow is beautiful when IT'S newly fallen

"It" for generic noncount nouns corresponds to the plural generic "they" for count nouns.

Marilyn
About snow, you can also say "Yes, I've seen SOME." This isn't a generic but it says that you've seen "a certain amount" of the mass noun "snow."

Marilyn

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×