Singular or plural

Hi, Sedo,

The answer is: 'both'.

In fact, your example above is wholly taken from Michael Swan, page: 522. He says:

"After expressions like one of the . .. , singular and plural verbs are both used in relative clauses beginning who, which or that.
She's one of the few women who have / has climbed Everest.
This is one of those books that are/is read by everybody.
Strictly speaking, a plural verb is correct (to agree with the few women who or
those books that). However, singular verbs are also very common in these
structures."

Hi, Sedo and Ahmed,

I agree with your answer, Ahmed. Both the singular and the plural form are commonly used in that construction by native speakers. The strict correctness of using the plural, however, becomes obvious when one rearranges the sentence:

(B1) She is one of the few women who have climbed Mount Everest.
(B2) Of the few women who have climbed Mount Everest, she is one.
(B3) *Of the few women who has climbed Mount Everest, she is one.

Add Reply

Likes (0)
×
×
×
×