Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

@Omar Ahmed posted:

Janet is the......of the two girls.

a. taller b. tallest

I think both 'a' & 'b' are OK. Am I right?

Hello, sir.

In 'Practical English Usage', M. Swan says "

groups with two members:

When a group only has two members, we sometimes use a comparative instead of a superlative.
I like Lily and Mia, but I think Mia’s the nicer/nicest of the two.
I'll give you the bigger/biggest steak: I'm not very hungry.
Some people feel that a superlative is incorrect in this case.

Also, in 'A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language',

'The superlative is often used for a comparison between two persons, items, etc [3], though this is avoided in careful usage where the comparative [3a] is preferred :
He is the youngest (of the two brothers). [3]
He is the younger (of the two brothers). [3a]

@ahmed_btm posted:

Hi, Omar and Ayman,

My answer above is the model answer, which I expect to find in a formal exam. Here's the comment of the editor of Longman on a similar question:

"It is safer on tests to use the comparative in a sentence such as this, but in informal usage both comparative and superlative are acceptable."

My answer doesn't go against yours, Ahmed. Read what my answer carefully, please.

Add Reply

Link copied to your clipboard.