Skip to main content

(Reposted from old newsgroup on 3/14/03)

Would you say:

There is a variety of ways in which a vacation can be spent.
or
There are a variety of ways in which a vacation can be spent.

I say "there is" because it has to agree with "variety" (singular), but some say "there are," or that both ways are correct.

What do you think?

Diane
Last edited {1}
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

(Reposted from old newsgroup on 3/14/03)

In a search in the Collins COBUILD Corpus Concordance Sampler online (http://titania.cobuild.collins.co.uk/form.html) under "There + IS + a + variety," The Grammar Exchange found three examples of the phrase with a plural count noun:

"...Instead, there is a variety of approaches, originating in...
...He said: 'Today there is a variety of things from which people need...
...This suggests that there is a variety of ways families can adapt...."

There are three additional examples of "there is a variety" + a noncount noun: "there is a variety of accomodation," "there is a variety of psychopathy," and "there is a variety of helpful literature."

The COBUILD lists 12 examples of "There + ARE + a + variety" + a plural count noun:

"...there are a variety of steps to be undertaken if a....
...there are a variety of packages to choose from.
...there are a variety of well stocked tarns, lakes and...
...There are a variety of resistance exercises available...
...there are a variety of ideas and methods in use but
...there are a variety of adult groups claiming an...
...There are a variety of things lenders can do to help.
...there are a variety of reasons for low birth weight.
...There are a variety of ways to do word sorts, but the
...there are a variety of nuclear power kinds of...
...there are a variety of useful edit windows like...
...there are a variety of uses that creative ..."

From this I think it is safe to conclude that "There ARE a variety" + a plural count noun is close to a standard, from a search of sub-corpora in which the COBUILD includes British books and media, American books and radio, and British transcribed speech. (The Corpus Concordance Sampler does not include conversation or fiction.) While "There IS a variety" + a plural count noun does occur, "There ARE a variety" + a plural count noun occurs four times as often.

Your sentence -- "There IS a variety of ways in which a vacation can be spent" - could be used. However, "there ARE a variety of ways in which a vacation can be spent" seems more acceptable and more comfortable.

For some interesting comments on a similar problem, see - "The/ a percentage is or the/ a percentage are." The posters are Betty Azar and Chuncan Feng.

Rachel
(Reposted from old newsgroup on 3/14/03)

My corpus search findings on A Variety of NP & was/were/is/are (my corpus, WEC, a collection of famous literary works, about 50 million words; the sentences, of different patterns, are simplified to save space):

Subject-Verb: Singular
NP: 5 plural, 2 singular
1. A variety of courses was open to her.
2. when a variety of very select foods and liquids was placed
3. there IS A VARIETY OF new distortions of the adjective to be learned
4. There WAS A VARIETY OF dishes much to his taste
5. there WAS A VARIETY OF cold dishes set off with jelly
1. We saw specimens of the kuabaoba, ..., which IS A VARIETY OF the white
2. there WAS A VARIETY OF excellence

Subject-Verb: Plural
NP: 10 plural
1. Hung about his neck by means of a cord WERE A VARIETY OF poems
2. here ARE A VARIETY OF amusements
3. there ARE A VARIETY OF rich columns
4. whilst a variety of rude implements of war were piled in confused heaps
5. On the sideboard a variety of miscellaneous articles were huddled together,
6. such a variety of Christian sects have followed the footsteps
7. To do this, a variety of improvements were necessary
8. a variety of fancy chops were administered on both sides
9. one could get a variety of foreign drinks which were kept for the visiting naval officers
10. a variety of queer smells were partially quenched

Chuncan Feng

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×