Skip to main content

December 2022

What does "some" add?

I've asked questions about this before, but I just saw this sentence: He located the squeak's source and applied some WD-40. What does "some" add here? We know that the person is applying an amount of WD-40 that is less than the total amount in the universe (obviously), so "some" can't be adding that information.Read More...
My thoughts exactly. Thanks, Gustavo. The idea we are exploring is that "the deal with adding 'some'" has to do with general versus specific situations. When the reference is to a specific situation, the idea of a certain quantity is present, so we naturally use "some": He was thirsty and drank some water. He is thirsty and would like some water. When the reference is to a general situation (a habit or regularity, not a specific instance of the habit or regularity), the idea of a certain...Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

ingrained in or into?

Hello Grammar Exchange members! I ran into the following paragraph in an article published in the New York Times. a. The issue of child labor has blighted the chocolate industry for decades; and despite coming to global attention over the past 10 years, it's a problem that won't go away. Systemic and deeply ingrained in the culture, its roots are found in the grinding poverty afflicting rural communities: farmers who can't afford to pay adult workers use children instead. I know the...Read More...
Yes. Sorry for the typo. Thanks a lot.Read More...
Last Reply By f6pafd · First Unread Post

Comparative and superlative

A : Who do you think is ………………….…..woman, Mona or her sister ? B : Mona, for sure. a- the most beautiful b- the more beautiful c- more beautiful d- a more beautifulRead More...
Yes, (b) ("the more beautiful woman") is correct and is surely the answer that the exam maker intended as the only correct one. However, (d) is also correct: Who do you think is a more beautiful woman, Mona or her sister? That means: "Is Mona a more beautiful woman than Mona's sister, or is Mona's sister a more beautiful woman than Mona?" As I said before, the sentence I recommend—the sentence a native speaker would likely use—is "Who do you think is more beautiful, Mona or her sister?"Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

Omission of verb

Is the verb "visited" needed in the following sentence? 1- I have visited more tourist spots than he has . 2- I have visited more tourist spots than he has visited . 3- I have visited more tourist spots than he has done .Read More...
Grammatically, all three are correct. Idiomatically, sentence 1 is the best. The verb "visited" can be omitted.Read More...
Last Reply By f6pafd · First Unread Post

whichever/whoever

1) Whichever student hands in their paper before Thursday will get extra points. 2) Whichever students hand in their paper before Thursday will get extra points. 3) Whichever of you hands in their paper before Thursday will get extra points. 4) Whichever one of you hands in their paper before Thursday will get extra points. 5) Whoever of you hands in their paper before Thursday will get extra points. 6) Whichever ones of you hand in their paper before Thursday will get extra points. Which...Read More...

became very popular ... to accompany steak

Hi. In the following sentence, what is the function of the boldfaced infinitive phrase? The sauce was first made in the UK in 1824 but it later became very popular in North America to accompany steak . I'd appreciate your help.Read More...
Hi, David. I have found some more sentences, in which their subjects function as the notional subjects of the infinitive: a) They were thoughtful to come home early. b) Anne was awful to leave her child on the train. c) John was nice to lend George the money. They apparently seem to be the same in form as the sentence under discussion, however, the infinitive phrase in them serves as an adverbial of reason for the comment on the subject, while in the sentence under discussion in the original...Read More...
Last Reply By f6pafd · First Unread Post

'That' vs 'where'

Is there any difference between the following sentences? 1- The restaurant that my cousin works at is really expensive. 2-The restaurant where my cousin works is really expensive.Read More...
Hi, Subhajit—There is not much difference at all between them. 1a) My cousin works at the restaurant . It is really expensive. 2a) My cousin works there . It is really expensive.Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

"to have lied"

Hi, In reading Demian by Hermann Hesse, I found the following sentence in Chapter 6: Jacob Wrestles with God, Quote: "Then really you might have been a clergyman," I suggested. "No, Sinclair, no. I should have had to have lied in that case . Our religion is so practiced, as if it were none." End. In the sentence in bold, I am not clear what difference there is between "should have had to lie in that case" and "should have had to have lied in that case." Thanks always,Read More...
Hi, David. Great thanks for the reply. I have been wondering why the translator chose to use the expression and trying to dig up hidden connotation, if any. Thanks for your help, as always.Read More...
Last Reply By moon2 · First Unread Post

Admitted is Verb or Adjective

"Brazil football legend Pele, 80, is in a stable condition after “respiratory instability” last night led to him being admitted to an intensive care unit." Sir,the word "admitted" mentioned above sentence ADJECTIVE or VERB? And please explain the reason as well. Thank you in advance.Read More...
Hi, Sundaran—I agree with f6pafd's explanation. "Him being admitted to an intensive care unit" is a non-finite clause. It functions as the object of the preposition "to" in "led to." The verb group of the nonfinite clause is "being admitted." It is a passive verb phrase. Here is an active-voice correlate: He is in a stable condition after “respiratory instability” last night led to nurses admitting him to an intensive care unit.Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

I felt that it had to be John

1) "I felt that it had to be John." I assume the meaning of the above sentence is " I felt it was supposed to be John. " OR "I felt that it must be (past= had to be) John." 2) The couple I met yeterday, they had to be brother and sister I assume "the couple I met yeterday, they were supposed to be brother and sister." OR the couple I met yeterday, they must be brother and sister. (Past = had to be) Please correct me Sir🙏Read More...
Hi, Sundaran—Your paraphrase of (1) that uses "was supposed to" does not work, but your paraphrase with "must be" is correct. Both of your paraphrases are possible; the sentence is technically ambiguous in that way. In the absence of context, my natural assumption is that the speaker meant: "Surely the couple I met yesterday were brother and sister."Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

Should I use tailor to?

Should I use tailor to? We tailor your business structure as your business evolves and take tremendous pride in our ability to leverage our knowledge and experience into the best strategies.Read More...
So like this: We tailor to your business structure as your business evolves and take tremendous pride in our ability to leverage our knowledge and experience into the best strategiesRead More...
Last Reply By Tony C · First Unread Post

Second Conditional

Hello Grammar Exchange members! I have a question about the second conditional (If+past simple, would+infinitive). a. If they are on a highway, it would be equivalent to not knowing you should stop at a stop sign. I know that 'are' should be replaced with 'were' in a. But I'm wondering if 'are' can be used in the sentence above somehow, but the meaning of the sentence slightly changes. I don't know the changed meaning if 'are' can change the meaning of the sentence. Thanks in advance. KDogRead More...
Thanks for your replay. I read the sentence in an article published in the New York Times. The following text is a part of the article. News, or media, literacy — how to critically understand, analyze and evaluate online content, images and stories — is not new. But it has taken on urgency in the last few years as accusations of fake news and the reality of disinformation permeate the internet and people — especially young ones — spend hours and hours a day looking at screens. “Media...Read More...
Last Reply By KDog · First Unread Post

Articles

The word 'criminal' is both a noun and ( an ) adjective My question is `The indefinite article (an) here is necessary or not? 'Read More...
Hello, Emad—The article "an" is important there. It creates parallelism and indicates that "criminal" as an adjective is different from "criminal" as a noun. That said, the sentence is understandable without "an" before "adjective."Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

has been to & has gone to

My friend (has been- has gone) to Qatar to watch the world cup. Now he is on his way to his country Egypt. I know that has been to means went and came back whereas has gone to means went and is still there . However in the example above I’n confused as the subject has already left Qatar but hasn’t come back to Egypt yet . Thanks in advanceRead More...
"has been to" should be used in the above context. As long as he has left Qatar, "has gone to" should not be used. It does not matter whether he has come back or not.Read More...
Last Reply By f6pafd · First Unread Post

The usage of SWEAR

He swears to be here on time next week. It's a conventional usage. What about these: He swears not to have met her yesterday! He swears not meeting her yesterday! He swears not having met her yesterday!Read More...
Hi, Me_IV—Yes, that sentence is OK. I'd use "promises" rather than "swears," but "swears" could be used for emphasis. I find that extremely unnatural, though it is understandable. A "that"-clause would be far more natural: "He swears (that) he didn't meet her yesterday." Those are totally ungrammatical. They can be fixed by adding "to": He swears to not meeting her yesterday. He swears to not having met her yesterday.Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

what she said/has said/says/will say

- Tomorrow, she will tell me what she has made up her mind with. a) Will you tell me what she said? b) Will you tell me what she has said? c) Will you tell me what she says? d) Will you tell me what she will say? Are all possible and correct? I think that they mean different things.Read More...
Thank you, but my question is not about rephrasing it for the sake of rephrasing. Why did you switch to "Would you kindly tell me"? Nothing is wrong with "Will you tell me". This is how I understand these: a) Will you tell me what she said? - CORRECT b) Will you tell me what she has said? - dubious c) Will you tell me what she says? - may mean the same as 1 d) Will you tell me what she will say? - will you predict what she will say?Read More...
Last Reply By Me_IV · First Unread Post

will expire vs is expiring

Your SSH key is expiring soon. Please update to a new one. Why it is "is expiring" instead of WILL or GOING TO/ GOING TO BE?Read More...

The usage of HAVE in continuous with habitual actions

As far as I know it's not correct to use HAVE in the present continuous with habitual actions. 1 I am always having a good time when I go to the sea. (wrong) But supposing, I want to say the following: 2 When I arrive at her house, she is having a good time. If I say 3 When I arrive at her house, she has a good time. It will mean that I arrive first and then she starts having a good time. But I want to say that by the moment I arrive she has been having a good time. To summarize: 3 is...Read More...
Good point Davit! I think I have finally understood the reason why it works differently in different contexts.Read More...
Last Reply By Me_IV · First Unread Post

your children’s past will be in part your present

Hi, everyone. To some degree, we understand, however, that the segregation of our consciousness into present, past, and future is both a fiction and an oddly self-referential framework; your present was part of your mother’s future, and your children’s past will be in part your present. (Source: The Pivotal Generation by Henry Shue) Q. I am confused about the meaning of the bold part because of 'in part'. If we paraphrase the bold part, which is correct? 1) Part of your children's past will...Read More...
Thank you, David and Gustavo. Venn Diagram helped me a lot. I really appreciate your kind answers. Luckily, I got an answer from the author, too. I thank all of you.Read More...
Last Reply By WinD · First Unread Post
×
×
×
×