Skip to main content

February 2021

the character of society as constituted

Hello, everyone, So excavation is invention/discovery or sculpture where archaeologists craft remains of the past into forms which are meaningful. The archaeological ‘record’ is, accordingly, not a record at all, but made, not given, ‘data’. ‘The past’ is gone and lost, and a fortiori, through the equivocality of things and the character of society as constituted through meaning, never existed as a definitive entity ‘the present’ anyway. An archaeologist has a raw material, the remains of...Read More...
Much appreciate your comment with note, Gustavo! Best RGDS,Read More...
Last Reply By deepcosmos · First Unread Post

be present/should be present

1) Jane insisted that Tom be present at the ceremony tomorrow. 2) Jane insisted that Tom should be present at the ceremony tomorrow. Do '1' and '2' mean the same? 3) Cathy suggested that the ceremony be held outdoors. 4) Cathy suggested that the ceremony should be held outdoors. Do '3' and '4' mean the same? Gratefully, NaviRead More...
Hi, Ahmed—With "will be present," Navi's sentences (1) and (2) would have a different meaning entirely. Navi's sentences are about Jane's desire to bring about Tom's presence at the meeting tomorrow through her insistence. If, instead of the subjunctive or its "should"-equivalent, we used "will be present," Navi's sentences (1) and (2) would instead be about Jane's confidence about a future fact, namely, that Tom will indeed be present at the meeting.Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

Couldn't or shouldn'

Our new hire is exactly what we needed. We . ............. asked for a better employee a.shouldn't'! have b.wouldn't have c.couldn't have. d. may have I tend to choose ( couldn' t have). What do you think?Read More...
Hi, Ahmed and Ahmed—I agree with both of you that "couldn't have" is the correct answer. The other answer choices, while not ungrammatical, each express a meaning that is silly in the context—so silly I want to laugh out loud.Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

How to use it

You don't have to make me look silly in public. How can we use "show" in this sentence, please?Read More...
Hello, M.Mamdouh, and welcome to the Grammar Exchange. Your question is not clear. Are you looking for a verbal idiom involving the word "show" which can be used in a sentence with a similar meaning to that of "You don't have to make me look silly in public"? If so, you can say: You don't have to show me up .Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

use of the verb with "to" or "ing" form

Hello, Could you please tell me why these sentences are correct: " Then, they began to harass me" and "The other customers began looking at us"? We have the same verb in both, which is "began". So if I say "Then, they began harassing me" and "The other customers began to look at us", are they still correct? I'm guessing my confusion here is: which form is correct after the verb "began" (to+verb OR gerund)? I'll truly appreciate if you can give further explanation on that. Thank you so much!Read More...
All right. Thank you so much =)Read More...
Last Reply By JessyA · First Unread Post

Good to speak with you today

Are the two sentences below grammatically correct? 1. Good to speak with you today! 2. Nice speaking with you today!Read More...
Yes, Tony. Both are correct, but while (1) can refer to the present or the past (the conversation that is about to take place or the conversation that just took place), (2) can only refer to a recent past conversation. The constructions above can derive from the sentences that follow: 1a. It is good to speak with you today. 1b. It was good to speak with you today. 1. It was nice speaking with you today.Read More...
Last Reply By Gustavo, Co-Moderator · First Unread Post

Articles instead of possessive pronouns

Hi All! I have a logic/grammar/style question mark about replacing possessive pronouns with a or the . For example, take a look at the following phrase: to combine my philosophical skill with my passion for sharing knowledge To make the sentence sound more interesting, I would like to replace the second my with a or the : to combine my philosophical skill with a passion for sharing knowledge to combine my philosophical skill with the passion for sharing knowledge However, I am unsure whether...Read More...
Thank you, Gustavo!Read More...
Last Reply By funnelheart · First Unread Post

Subjunctive influencing reported speech

It would be the same if he <asked/were to ask> me where I < was/were/am... > Hi. I made the sentence myself. The past subjunctive "asked / were to ask" is being used to express a hypothetical situation. I'm thinking about which form of "to be" should be used in the subordinate clause. Questions 1. If the corresponding direct speech is "where are you now?", need "am" be back shifted? My guess: optional, so "am, was" both are fine. 2. If the corresponding direct speech is in past...Read More...
Hi, Robby zhu—Although it is not part of your official two questions, I thought you might be interested to know that "were" is incorrect in the where-clause: *" It would be the same if he asked/were to ask me where I were ." From a native-speaking standpoint, backshifting "am" to "was" is desirable. Yes: " It would be the same if he asked me were to ask me where I had been . " Technically, however, "was" can be an absolute or a relative tense there.Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

Focus structures

Tom is working as a dental assistant. What he does is(clean_ to clean_ cleaning_cleans) I have come across this sentence in OXford Practice Grammar. I think we two correct answers:"clean/to clean".Read More...
Yes, "clean" and "to clean" are both correct there. I would only use "clean"; "to clean" ("What he does is to clean") sounds very unnatural to me. Interestingly, those two answers assume that the pseudo-cleft sentence derives from the basic sentence "He cleans." But if the basic sentence is "He does cleaning," the pseudo-cleft sentence related to that is "What he does is cleaning."Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

adjective positioning

I have encountered examples of the effect of adjective position on the meaning. the concerned parents (= the parents who are worried) the parents concerned (= the parents who are involved/mentioned) Could anyone please elaborate on the difference, and how can I analyze it. BTW, I am not a native speaker. ThanksRead More...
Thanks a zillion timesRead More...
Last Reply By vahidkiaa · First Unread Post

Usage of the word "Politics," and "Political"

Hello, I am confused about the usage of the word "political." Can the word be used to describe the way any group makes decisions or does it exclusively apply to formal organizations like governments and companies? For example, is the use of the word political in these sentences correct or not? Political tension between the two cast members got Rick voted off the island on the tv show survivor. The show, Survivor, is a game show that displays the political behavior of people in groups. It is...Read More...
Hi, Dave, You had already asked the same question here . Sorry we didn't answer it earlier. Actually, it might be considered a sociological rather than a linguistic question. Personally, I think that "politics" and "political" can, by extension, be used to refer to power struggles and competition for leadership in informal groups. We have, for example, the popular phrase "politically correct" to describe a diplomatic behavior in any field. We can infer that "political" can be used to refer...Read More...
Last Reply By Gustavo, Co-Moderator · First Unread Post

Why do we have the particles "we have"

Hello, everyone, "Reflecting on the extremely rare occasions in which we fundamentally reframe our understanding of the universe causes us to think carefully about the limits on the role of science. Science is the art of measuring and of developing models to produce predictions. Discussions about scientific models often provoke deeper questions about why the universe is in the condition it is in. What actually is electrical charge? Why is there a gravitational pull between objects? Why do we...Read More...
Hello, David, Much appreciate your guide unexpected. Fully noted. Best RGDS,Read More...
Last Reply By deepcosmos · First Unread Post

looked or was looking

Hello! I came across this sentence: He looked at it for a long time. Question: Since this sentence has the phrase "for a long time" is it correct to use Past Siple in it? Why don't we say "was looking" here (Past Continuous)?Read More...
David, thanks a lot! Now, I can see the nuances of using the two tenses in this sentence! This is the best forum for English learners! Glad I found it)Read More...
Last Reply By Inna · First Unread Post

I think I’m lucky to have such a good neighbor-slash-friend.

Hi What is meaning of "-slash-" in neighbor-slash-friend? I think I’m lucky to have such a good neighbor- slash-friend.Read More...
Hi, TaeBbongE—When you quote sentences here, you need to site the source. (Please see the Guidelines page.) Wherever you got the sentence, I am guessing that it occurred in spoken discourse rather than in writing. "Slash" refers to the punctuation mark "/." It's an informal way of indicating that one could equally be talking about either thing. "Slash" in your example denotes "/"; the speaker would use it if he/she were writing the sentence.Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

used to / got used to

Please , I would like to as if the two following sentences give the same meaning or not and why? 1-He used to eat a lot . 2 He got / was used to eating a lotRead More...
Hi, Adel and welcome to the G.E, 'Used to' is a semi-modal used when we refer to things in the past which are no longer true. Here, it is used to describe a habitual action in the past. - He used to eat a lot in the past, but now he doesn't as he knows it is unhealthy. There is a difference in meaning between 'got used to' and 'was used to'. 2. He was used to eating a lot. ' Used ' here is adjectival and synonymous with ' accustomed '. The focus here isn't on the action (eating), but on the...Read More...
Last Reply By ahmed_btm · First Unread Post

keep it a secret that clause

Hello, everyone! Since I have sometimes seen following sentences based on the verb ‘keep’, are they grammatically correct? 1. Keep it a secret that I am a man. (single sentence only) 2. We kept it a secret that Jerome was insane. (single sentence only) 3. Normally, when I keep some information secret, I also keep it a secret that I believe or know this. * source; https://books.google.co.kr/boo...lieve%22&f=false My point is that the verb ‘keep’ can take a preparatory ‘it’ with an...Read More...
Hello, David, Thank you million times! Best RGDSRead More...
Last Reply By deepcosmos · First Unread Post

Coloured vs colourful

Please, would you explain the difference between coloured and colourful. I' be read this text: ( People love visiting the reef because there are so many colourful fish that live there. In the past, all of the reef used to have beautifully coloured coral. My question_: Why is ( colourful) with fish whereas ( coloured) with coral? May be coral has one colour, What do you think?Read More...
According to the dictionary: - colored: having a color other than black or white - colorful: having bright colors or a lot of different colorsRead More...
Last Reply By Gustavo, Co-Moderator · First Unread Post

maybe, may be, will.

Hello. Could you please help me choose the correct answer? Why? - A: Will your plane be late this afternoon? B: It (maybe - may be - will). The airport was closed this afternoon. Thank you.Read More...
Hello, Ahmed—"Maybe" is not an alternative way of writing "may be." "Maybe" is an adverb; "may be" is a modal ("may") followed by the verb "be." Both "may be" and "will" work as possible responses in that rather odd interaction, which I hope isn't part of an exam. I'd just use "may": "It may."Read More...
Last Reply By David, Moderator · First Unread Post

my friends growing up

1) All of my friends growing up are celebrities now. Is that sentence grammatical? a) I think people say that kind of thing, but it sounds strange to me. The idea is: All of those who were my friends when I was growing up are celebrities now. I don't see how '1' can be parsed to mean 'a'. I think it is just an idiomatic usage that doesn't correspond to the rules of grammar. Gratefully, NaviRead More...
Hi, Navi, There are many examples of that usage on COCA. Grammatically, "growing up" would be similar to a dangling participle, the sentence above being a colloquial way of saying: 2) All the friends I had as I grew up/as a child are celebrities now.Read More...
Last Reply By Gustavo, Co-Moderator · First Unread Post

position

Hello. What's wrong with the following sentence or is it correct? I think it is correct. - We watched as the waiter expertly positioned the turkey we ordered. Thank you.Read More...
Hi, Ahmed, I see nothing wrong with the sentence above. We can find an "as"-clause after the verb watch to describe the situation being watched. Compare: - We watched the waiter as he expertly positioned the turkey we ordered. (The waiter was watched while he did the action.) - We watched as the waiter expertly positioned the turkey we ordered. (The action as a whole was watched.)Read More...
Last Reply By Gustavo, Co-Moderator · First Unread Post

couldn't go, can't have gone

Hello. I think both choices are correct in the following sentence, right? - Because we were young, we (couldn't go - can't have gone) to the swimming pool alone. Thank you.Read More...
You are right, Ahmed. Both are correct but different in meaning. Because we were young, we couldn't go to the swimming pool alone can be used to refer to a usual inability: because they were young, they were (permanently) unable or not allowed to go to the swimming pool alone. Because we were young, we can't have gone (also couldn't have gone ) to the swimming pool alone can be used to make a deduction about the past. However, I find the adverbial clause of reason at the beginning of the...Read More...
Last Reply By Gustavo, Co-Moderator · First Unread Post
×
×
×
×